View profile

Beyond Fundamentals 🍔

Beyond Fundamentals 🍔
By Making smalltalk • Issue #27 • View online

As someone who often invests in the U.S. stock market, I keep myself updated on big developments happening there. Not only does the big economic picture impact Indian stocks, there’s also a lot of interesting companies & sectors that a developed stock market like the U.S. offers.
Take the IPO & subsequent bull-run of Beyond Meat, for example. Beyond Meat listed on NASDAQ in May 2019 at an offering of $25, and was up almost 1,000% in less than 3 months!


Source: NASDAQ & Google Finance
Source: NASDAQ & Google Finance
On Monday after market-close, the firm announced its second ever quarterly results as a public company - and the results were quite stellar:
  • The company reported its first ever quarterly profit, 6 months after its blockbuster IPO
  • Earnings per share (EPS) of $0.06 easily beat analyst estimates of $0.03
  • Net sales rose 250% to $92 million, topping expectations of $82.2 million
  • Moreover, the company even raised its outlook for the year - a rather positive surprise for most investors/shareholders
It’s one thing for a company to do well. It’s completely another to beat the expectations of the street so convincingly - these results are probably what most companies (and shareholders) dream of.
Yet, the stock of Beyond Meat was down ~20% on Tuesday, the day after the results were announced. So what exactly happened?
The short answer is that there are technical forces & sentiments at play. While the optimistic bull-run in this stock has been fantastic - so much so, that even after the downslide on Tuesday, the stock still remains up more than 300% from its IPO price.
But most of the early investors in Beyond Meat, including the senior management, had most of their shares locked-in during this period. In fact, about 80% of the company’s total outstanding shares were subject t0 this lock-up!
This lock-up period expired on Tuesday. And this led to fears amongst existing investors that this new liquidity (i.e. increased supply of shares available to trade) will result in a sell-off and a decline in the stock price.
Analysts even came out with reports saying they’re expecting a sell-off due to this reason. But interestingly enough - during the earnings call, CEO Ethan Brown clearly said he’s not looking to sell any of his shares:
“Why would I? I’m entirely focused on long term.. It can be a $40 billion global protein company.”
There were no other comments from the other top 4 investors as well. Yet, despite the spectacular results & the endorsement from its CEO, the stock crashed by more than 20% on Tuesday.
One reason is that indeed some early investors could’ve cashed out by selling some of their shares. We’ll only know this in a few months time when such data becomes publicly available. This would be the one technical reason.
The other, and equally important reason in my opinion, would be expectations & sentiments. Since many existing investors were expecting this to happen, they tried to pre-empt this by selling their shares before others.
And in doing so, investors themselves created the sell-off that they were expecting to happen. Even though the results announced exceeded expectations & clearly showed the company is fundamentally robust & growing.
Reading this was a good reminder of how expectations & sentiments can often override fundamental reasons in the short-run, whether they are justified or not.
This phenomena isn’t unique to the US stock market - it’s a trait of humankind & as such witnessed across the entire globe, including our very own India.
Such instances provide an insight/reminder as to how such mass markets (which the stock exchange truly is) really function. And that while fundamentals of a company are important to the core, sometimes the market’s expectations & sentiments go beyond fundamentals.
Happy investing!
-Vikas Bardia, CFA
Recommended Reads
81% of ELSS funds play catch-up with their benchmark
McKinsey’s report finds a majority of global banks are not viable
From Our Blog
The Glittering History of Gold - Making smalltalk
#TweetTweet
Fortune India
Smallcase Technologies is trying to ignite investor interest by offering an alternative to mutual funds. Its run has been good so far. Next? A million-strong investor base by March 2020. https://t.co/gtr76p93lh
6:33 PM - 23 Oct 2019
Did you enjoy this issue?
Making smalltalk

Investment insights, views, and news delivered to your inbox every alternate Wednesday.

If you don't want these updates anymore, please unsubscribe here
If you were forwarded this newsletter and you like it, you can subscribe here
Powered by Revue